Back to Search Results

901 Maupin Avenue, New Haven, MO, 63068

Originally constructed circa 1887, this extraordinary Gothic Revival church has been thoughtfully transformed into one of New Haven’s most unforgettable residences. Formerly known as Trinity Hill Bed & Breakfast, this approximately 1,860 sq ft property beautifully marries more than a century of history and architectural character with the comforts and conveniences of modern living as a renovated residence! Step inside the former sanctuary and prepare to be captivated. Soaring approximately 20-foot cathedral ceilings create a breathtaking sense of scale, while six magnificent Gothic arched windows with rich amber stained glass filter warm light throughout the expansive main living space. Six custom and carefully designed lantern-style chandeliers draw the eye upward and complement the building’s historic character, while beautiful oak flooring brings warmth beneath your feet. At approximately 1,000 sq ft, the former sanctuary provides an incredible open-concept living and entertaining space unlike anything found in a traditional home. The history continues throughout a property that has served its community in many forms over the decades, including as a church and even the town library. Today, those remarkable architectural details provide the backdrop for a truly distinctive residence. The former altar area has been transformed into a beautiful, well-appointed full kitchen, blending seamlessly into the dramatic main space. Designer cabinetry, granite countertops and a focal center island with gas cooktop provide modern functionality while maintaining the open, social atmosphere of the original sanctuary. An adjacent butler's pantry provides space and functionality. Thoughtfully placed bedroom provides privacy without sacrificing the openness that makes this property so special, while the great room provides plent of space to be able to add additional bedrooms. Updated bath features ceramic tile and a spacious walk-in shower just off the main bedroom. A front entrance "foyer" could be transformed into an additional bedroom, or private sitting area. All the details of this amazing building pay homage to the building’s storied past. Outside, the prominent corner bell tower immediately announces that this is no ordinary property. Situated on a corner lot with off-street parking, additional rear parking and space previously utilized for larger vehicles, the property is located just blocks from New Haven’s historic downtown, local shops and restaurants and the Missouri River. Perhaps most intriguing is the versatility this remarkable property presents. Continue enjoying it as an unforgettable private residence, create an extraordinary weekend retreat, or explore the possibilities offered by its history as the former Trinity Hill Bed & Breakfast, subject to applicable zoning, permitting and approvals. This isn't simply a converted church—it is a piece of New Haven history that has been preserved, reimagined and given an entirely new life. From the soaring sanctuary and Gothic stained glass to the bell tower, dramatic chandeliers and modern kitchen, 901 Maupin Avenue offers the rare opportunity to own a home that truly cannot be duplicated.

Subdivision: Wm T Norths

List Price

$ 162,000

Status

Active

Days on market

0

MLS#

26059331

Bedrooms

1

Full baths

2

Sq. Ft. Above

1,860

Subdivision

Wm T Norths

Municipality

New Haven

School District

New Haven

County

Franklin

Property Type

Residential

Style

Historic,Other

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2025)

$1,029

Recent Nearby Sales in 63068

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
6 acres SUNSET Lane, New Haven, MO 63068 0/0 -- $129,900 $120,000
92.4% of ask
Sep 17, 2026
302 Heritage Valley Drive, New Haven, MO 63068 3/2 1,500 $358,000 $358,334
100.1% of ask
Sep 17, 2026
139 Phillip Lane, New Haven, MO 63068 3/2 1,814 $550,000 $535,000
97.3% of ask
Sep 17, 2026
311 Heritage Valley Drive, New Haven, MO 63068 0/0 -- $29,900 $26,000
87% of ask
Sep 9, 2026
313 Heritage Valley Drive, New Haven, MO 63068 0/0 -- $29,900 $26,000
87% of ask
Sep 9, 2026
1004 Miller Street, New Haven, MO 63068 2/1 730 $130,000 $130,000
100% of ask
Sep 4, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale
Sep 17, 2026 at $162,000
Current status: Active
As of Sep 17, 2026 · $162,000

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A Guerrilla Brokers, LLC agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.

Room Dimensions

Room Type

Sitting Room

Room Dimensions

14x7

Room Description

Foyer sitting room

Great Room

37x26

Cathedral ceilings, replica church lighting, hardwoods

Kitchen

12x9

Custom remodeled kitchen, 42" uppers, granite, Island breakfast bar, granite counter, butlers pantry, gas stove/cooktop

Bedroom

12x11

Washer/Dryer Hookup laundry closet, double closet, tray ceiling, can lighting

Bathroom

7x6

Custom walk-in, tiled shower, adult height granite vanity

Other

6x6

Butlers Pantry, granite, soft close, stainless refrigerator