Back to Search Results
$220,000sold price Closed

5417 Grace Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63116

2 bd | 1 ba | 1,593 sq ft | Craftsman
Subdivision: P J Fendlers
Welcome to this beautifully preserved 1925 Craftsman nestled in the heart of the highly sought-after Holly Hills neighborhood. From the moment you arrive, the home's distinctive multi-colored brick exterior and expansive covered front porch create an inviting first impression that perfectly reflects the timeless character found throughout. Step inside to discover a spacious living room showcasing gleaming hardwood floors, original millwork, stunning stained glass windows, and an ornamental fireplace flanked by elegant leaded glass built-in bookcases. The adjoining formal dining room features another beautiful stained glass window and an ornate stained glass chandelier, while the graceful arched opening with built-in display ledges and coved ceiling highlights the exceptional craftsmanship of the era. The updated eat-in kitchen blends historic charm with modern convenience, offering walls of cabinetry, abundant countertop space, tiled walls and backsplash, and updated stainless steel appliances. Two generously sized bedrooms with ceiling fan lighting share a beautifully preserved full bath featuring rare original Vitrolite glass wall panels. A convenient mud room just off the kitchen provides easy access to the backyard. The partially finished walk-out lower level offers outstanding flexibility with a spacious recreation area, bonus room, large walk-in closet, and plenty of additional storage. Outside, you'll enjoy a fully fenced backyard complete with a large paver stone patio and walkway leading to the detached one-car garage—an ideal space for entertaining, relaxing, or gardening. Additional updates include a brand-new roof and energy-efficient vinyl windows throughout, providing peace of mind while preserving the home's historic appeal. Whether you're searching for timeless architectural character, modern updates, or one of South St. Louis' most desirable neighborhoods, this Holly Hills Craftsman delivers. Contact your full-time Realtor today with any questions or to schedule your private showing before this exceptional home is gone!

Status: Closed · MLS# 26046590 · Listing Courtesy of MORE, REALTORS, [email protected]
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.

Approximate location. Get directions

Talk to a real agent about this home

StLouisRealEstate.com is operated by Guerrilla Brokers, LLC. The person who answers is a licensed real estate agent with Missouri Online Real Estate, Inc. who can pull this listing up with you and answer your questions about it.

Call now
Calls may be recorded.*
Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Facts and features

Sold Price

$ 220,000

List Price

$ 220,000

Status

Closed

Days on market

33

MLS#

26046590

Bedrooms

2

Full baths

1

Sq. Ft. Above

1,593

Sq. Ft. Below

373

Subdivision

P J Fendlers

Municipality

St Louis City

School District

St. Louis City

County

St Louis City

Property Type

Residential

Style

Craftsman

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2025)

$2,265

Recent Nearby Sales in 63116

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
4725 Hummel Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63116 3/1 800 $225,000 $213,000
94.7% of ask
Nov 18, 2026
4133 Connecticut Street, St Louis City, MO 63116 3/3 1,976 $389,900 $380,000
97.5% of ask
Nov 16, 2026
3950 Loughborough Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63116 3/3 1,960 $249,000 $275,000
110.4% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
4123 Haven Street, St Louis City, MO 63116 2/2 1,188 $270,000 $270,000
100% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
5335 Alfred Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63116 2/2 1,100 $190,000 $185,000
97.4% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
4546 Varrelmann Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63116 2/2 1,254 $105,000 $100,000
95.2% of ask
Nov 12, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale at $220,000
Aug 6, 2026
Sold for $220,000
Sep 8, 2026 · 100% of original list price · 33 days from listing to closing

Every time this home was on the market

Prior listings, expired and canceled listings, days on market, price changes and sold prices from MARIS MLS records.

Loading…

Most MLS-recorded sales near this home

Most closed sales in the last 12 months around this address, listing side and buyer side, plus this listing agent's record.

Loading…

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A Missouri Online Real Estate, Inc. agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.

Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Other homes for sale nearby

In St Louis, 63116, closest in price to this one. See all in 63116 →
4319 Eichelberger Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 4 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$220,000

Price drop $10,000 was $230,000
4319 Eichelberger Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
4bd | 2ba | 1,080sqft |$204/sqft |145 DOM |1 Story MLS#26039923
6707 Alexander Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 2 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$220,000

19 days on market
6707 Alexander Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
2bd | 2ba | 971sqft |$227/sqft |19 DOM |1 Story MLS#26059320
4427 Delor Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 3 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$219,000

Price drop $30,000 was $249,000
4427 Delor Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
3bd | 2ba | 1,296sqft |$169/sqft |69 DOM |1.5 Story MLS#26057801
7328 Leona Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 3 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$224,900

Price drop $10,100 was $235,000
7328 Leona Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
3bd | 2ba | 940sqft |$239/sqft |19 DOM |1 Story MLS#26069606
5001 Alexander Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 3 bed, 1 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$225,000

14 days on market
5001 Alexander Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
3bd | 1ba | 1,423sqft |$158/sqft |14 DOM |1 Story MLS#26070795
5916 Leona Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 1 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$215,000

21 days on market
5916 Leona Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
1bd | 2ba | 960sqft |$224/sqft |21 DOM |1 Story MLS#26068255
3833 French Court, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 2 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$214,900

7 days on market
3833 French Court, St Louis City, MO, 63116
2bd | 2ba | 850sqft |$253/sqft |7 DOM |1 Story MLS#26053189
4091 Blow Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116 - 3 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$214,000

Price drop $21,000 was $235,000
4091 Blow Street, St Louis City, MO, 63116
3bd | 2ba | 1,176sqft |$182/sqft |65 DOM |1 Story MLS#26059306