Back to Search Results
$385,000sold price Closed

5031 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109

5 bd | 2 ba | 2,686 sq ft | Historic
Subdivision: Christys Add
Welcome to this stunning century home located in the highly sought-after Southampton neighborhood. Originally a two-family, the thoughtful conversion to a single-family residence created an open, modern floor plan while preserving the home's timeless charm. Architectural highlights include original fireplace mantels with built-in bookshelves, stained glass windows and hardwood floors throughout. From the moment you step inside, you'll be drawn to the inviting, light-filled, and generously sized rooms. The main level offers a comfortable living room, formal dining room, two bedrooms, and a show-stopping kitchen featuring Quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, open shelving, and abundant storage. A lovely full bath completes the first floor. Upstairs, a flexible layout allows you to tailor the space to your needs. The current owners created a gorgeous owner's suite with an attached sitting area. There are three additional bedrooms and two bonus rooms--perfect for a home office, nursery, or creative space. A tastefully renovated bath completes the 2nd floor. Additional features include zoned HVAC (2 years old) and tankless hot water heater (1 year old). Out back is a large level fenced yard with a concrete pad--great spot for a patio or potential parking. Ideally located near restaurants, shopping, and many of St. Louis's finest attractions, this home is truly move-in ready. Come see it for yourself and fall in love!

Status: Closed · MLS# 26004964 · Listing Courtesy of Garcia Properties, [email protected]
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.

Approximate location. Get directions

Talk to a real agent about this home

StLouisRealEstate.com is operated by Guerrilla Brokers, LLC. The person who answers is a licensed real estate agent with Missouri Online Real Estate, Inc. who can pull this listing up with you and answer your questions about it.

Call now
Calls may be recorded.*
Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Facts and features

Sold Price

$ 385,000

List Price

$ 375,000

Status

Closed

Days on market

37

MLS#

26004964

Bedrooms

5

Full baths

2

Sq. Ft. Above

2,686

Subdivision

Christys Add

Municipality

St Louis City

School District

St. Louis City

County

St Louis City

Property Type

Residential

Style

Historic

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2025)

$5,520

Room Dimensions

Main level
Living Room
0X0 Level i
Dining Room
0X0 Level i
Kitchen
0X0 Level i
Bedroom
0X0 Level i
Bedroom 2
0X0 Level i
Second
Bathroom 3
0X0 Level c
Bedroom 4
0X0 Level c
Bedroom 5
0X0 Level c
Family Room
0X0 Level c
Bonus Room
0X0 Level c
Bonus Room
0X0 Level c

Recent Nearby Sales in 63109

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
6349 Murdoch Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63109 3/3 1,752 $595,000 $595,000
100% of ask
Nov 17, 2026
5748 Devonshire Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63109 2/2 1,137 $280,000 $285,000
101.8% of ask
Nov 17, 2026
6413 Hampton Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63109 0/0 -- $1,800 $1,800
100% of ask
Nov 17, 2026
7058 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63109 3/3 1,536 $339,900 $339,900
100% of ask
Nov 16, 2026
5202 Delor Street, St Louis City, MO 63109 2/2 1,022 $1,500 $1,500
100% of ask
Nov 13, 2026
5746 Milentz Avenue, St Louis City, MO 63109 4/2 1,990 $350,000 $345,000
98.6% of ask
Nov 13, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale at $375,000
Jan 28, 2026
Sold for $385,000
Mar 6, 2026 · 102.7% of original list price · 37 days from listing to closing

Every time this home was on the market

Prior listings, expired and canceled listings, days on market, price changes and sold prices from MARIS MLS records.

Loading…

Most MLS-recorded sales near this home

Most closed sales in the last 12 months around this address, listing side and buyer side, plus this listing agent's record.

Loading…

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A Missouri Online Real Estate, Inc. agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.

Video or audio, usually in about 2 minutes. How it works

Other homes for sale nearby

In St Louis, 63109, closest in price to this one. See all in 63109 →
5120 McCausland Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 2 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$375,000

45 days on market
5120 McCausland Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109
2bd | 2ba | 1,378sqft |$272/sqft |45 DOM |1 Story MLS#26059421
5253 Devonshire Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 3 bed, 3 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$379,000

Price drop $20,000 was $399,000
5253 Devonshire Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109
3bd | 3ba | 2,116sqft |$179/sqft |76 DOM |2.5 Story MLS#26054879
5321 Nottingham Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 3 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$369,900

Open House
5204 Lindenwood Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 3 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$369,900

Price drop $20,100 was $390,000
5204 Lindenwood Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109
3bd | 2ba | 1,512sqft |$245/sqft |84 DOM |2 Story MLS#26047536
6347 Mardel Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 3 bed, 3 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO
Pending

$369,000

Price drop $30,000 was $399,000
6347 Mardel Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109
3bd | 3ba | 2,547sqft |$145/sqft |54 DOM |2 Story MLS#26056230
3621 Watson Road, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 5 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$389,900

Price drop $10,000 was $399,900
3621 Watson Road, St Louis City, MO, 63109
5bd | 2ba | 1,946sqft |$200/sqft |103 DOM |2 Story MLS#26043850
5620 Goethe Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 4 bed, 2 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO

$358,000

2 days on market
5620 Goethe Avenue, St Louis City, MO, 63109
4bd | 2ba | 1,100sqft |$325/sqft |2 DOM |1.5 Story MLS#26071870
5623 Walsh Street, St Louis City, MO, 63109 - 3 bed, 3 bath home for sale in St Louis, MO
Pending

$350,000

Price drop $10,000 was $360,000
5623 Walsh Street, St Louis City, MO, 63109
3bd | 3ba | 1,504sqft |$233/sqft |26 DOM |1.5 Story MLS#26056168