Back to Search Results

1889 Bay Avenue, Hannibal, MO, 63401

Stunning two-story brick home nestled on 3 acres in Hannibal, offering the perfect blend of country living and convenience. This beautifully built and maintained CUSTOM home welcomes you with a grand two-story foyer and an elegant office. The expansive two-story living room boasts an elegant picture window and an upstairs walkway overlooking both the living area and foyer, creating an open, airy feel. The gourmet kitchen is appointed with granite countertops and flows seamlessly into a bright breakfast room, sunroom, and deck—perfect for enjoying tranquil views of the woods behind the home. The large master suite includes a luxurious en suite bathroom and a generous walk-in closet for ample storage. This home also features a spacious 24 X 36 3-car garage with an additional garage downstairs. The lower level offers plenty of space to relax and kick back with an additional living room, fire place ,and built ins - it also has room for exercise! The lower level hobby room and garage offer expansive shelving an work space. Situated at the back of Fette Orchard Subdivision, this private setting offers all the benefits of the Fette Orchard neighborhood without the HOA. Conveniently located near the country club golf course, schools, shopping, and close to Interstate 36 access. Hannibal Regional Hospital is also nearby. This is the ideal home for both luxury and accessibility. Furniture is negotiable. Schedule your showing today!

Subdivision: Hehmeyer

List Price

$ 614,900

Status

Active Under Contract

Days on market

0

MLS#

25041115

Bedrooms

4

Full baths

4

Sq. Ft. Above

4,300

Sq. Ft. Below

800

Subdivision

Hehmeyer

Municipality

Hannibal

School District

Hannibal 60

County

Marion

Property Type

Residential

Style

Traditional

Type

Residential

Additional Information

Property Tax (2024)

$4,573

Recent Nearby Sales in 63401

Last 6 closed homes in this zip.

Address Bd/Ba SqFt List Sold Closed
66 Homestead, Hannibal, MO 63401 6/3 1,792 $250,000 $250,000
100% of ask
Sep 4, 2026
220 N Hawkins Avenue, Hannibal, MO 63401 3/1 1,649 $42,000 $40,500
96.4% of ask
Sep 2, 2026
1035 Reservoir Street, Hannibal, MO 63401 3/2 1,200 $185,000 $185,000
100% of ask
Sep 2, 2026
1209 Fulton Avenue, Hannibal, MO 63401 2/1 1,068 $78,000 $78,000
100% of ask
Aug 31, 2026
3001 Saint Marys Avenue, Hannibal, MO 63401 3/2 1,247 $189,000 $189,000
100% of ask
Aug 31, 2026
1526 Booker Street, Hannibal, MO 63401 2/1 1,144 $60,000 $60,000
100% of ask
Aug 31, 2026

Price & Listing History

Listed for sale
Jun 13, 2025 at $729,000
Price reduced by $114,100 (15.7%)
From $729,000 to $614,900
Current status: Active Under Contract
As of Jul 28, 2026 · $614,900

Mortgage Estimator

Estimate your monthly payment. Adjust the sliders below.

Estimated Monthly Payment
$0
Principal & Interest: $0 · Tax: $0 · Ins: $0
Loan Amount: $0
Total Interest: $0
Total of Payments: $0
A Guerrilla Brokers, LLC agent will connect you with a trusted local lender.

Estimate only. Not a loan offer. Consult a lender for an accurate quote, including HOA fees, PMI, and current rates.